Joseph's Brothers are Stuck

“Joseph’s Brothers Are Stuck”

Genesis 42:21-38

 

Today’s narrative proves that you certainly reap what you sow. The brothers' actions against Joseph have caught up with them. They have made the connection. 

Who would have thought this would have happened? 

Not in a million years. 

They still have no clue that the second in command of the entire nation of Egypt is their younger brother Joseph. And notice, Joseph is playing it for all it is worth. 

He is not about to let them down easily. 

And yet, he is not out for revenge either. 

 

Joseph has become a master chess player. He has been arranging all the pieces to see if the brothers have changed and he still has another piece to put into place to test his brothers. 

 

Today’s narrative opens with the brothers having been given a command from Joseph to prove they are honest men. They began to talk amongst themselves. Now remember, part of Joseph’s disguise was to have an interpreter. So the brothers are talking in Hebrew and assume that Joseph does not understand them, verse 21, 

“They said to one another, “Surely we are being punished because of our brother. We saw how distressed he was when he pleaded with us for his life, but we would not listen; that’s why this distress has come on us.”

Reuben chimes in, “Didn’t I tell you not to sin against the boy? But you wouldn’t listen! Now we must give an accounting for his blood.” 

Hyperlink - giving an account because of spilled blood. Remember the Cain and Abel story? 

The outcry of blood from the ground? 

Then there was Lamech, so much violence and blood shed that the outcry went up to God. That was right before the flood. 

Directly following the flood 

God makes a promise of no more cosmic de-creations like that, and God instructs Noah and his wife, just as He did with Adam and Eve, “Be fruitful and multiply, fill the land.” Yet, He added one change, 

the “rule over the animals” from Genesis 1 becomes “the fear and terror of you” on the animals. So what was once peace between humans and animals became conflict and terror between humans and animals. At this point the animals become food for the humans. 

Humans started out as vegans only to become omnivores. 

So what changed? Was this God’s ideal? Or a concession? 

God does concede to the fact humans are indeed violent and they love to kill everything that breathes, including each other. So, given that humans are that way, God offers a wider menu, but not without making it clear how this should be done. 

Basically all life belongs to God, so when a human takes the life of a living creature, the way to signal that the life belongs to Elohim was to pour the blood out. 

This is exactly what Reuben says, verse 22,

“Now we must give an accounting for his blood.”

Also in the brother’s discussion we get a bit more of the backstory, a flashback scene, where Joseph had been crying out from the pit.

In fact, Joseph was crying as he listened to them talk. 

Joseph composes himself, returns to the brothers, takes Simeon and binds him up. Joseph then gave orders for his brother's bags to be filled with grain, his servants were to to put each man’s silver back in his sack, without them knowing and to give provisions for the journey. The brothers load everything onto their donkeys and leave for home.

Along the way home, they stop for the night and one brother happens to open his sack to feed his donkey and lo and behold, he sees his silver sitting on top. He pulls it out to show his brothers and says, verse 28,

“My silver has been returned. Here it is in my sack.”

Their hearts sank and they turned to each other trembling and said, “What is this that God has done to us?”

In the back of their minds they know that the blood is required and they are afraid. 

They return home to their father Jacob and they tell him everything. In fact, they overshare the oversharing they provided Joseph. They don’t hide a thing from their father. 

Maybe the fear of Elohim has caused them to actually speak the truth? 

The last time they came to their father regarding Joseph they had gotten the money from selling him,                    had eaten bread,                                                                  Joseph was gone and                                                               they lied to their father. 

This time, they have the money and the bread,              they have left another brother behind and                       they tell everything to their father. 

 

No sooner had they finished telling their story and they began emptying their sacks, they discovered each brother’s sack contained his pouch of silver. 

Again, they saw the money pouches and they were frightened. 

Do,do,do,dooo.

Jacob takes it personally, and immediately blames his sons, verse 36,

“You have deprived me of my children. Joseph is no more and Simeon is no more, and now you want to take Benjamin. Everything is against me!”

Jacob certainly hasn’t changed much as he’s grown older. 

Then check out Reuben’s solution, verse 37,

“You may put both of my sons to death if I do not bring him back to you. Entrust him to my care, and I will bring him back.”

Oh, like I will bereave you of your grandchildren, that should help. 

Jacob doesn’t even respond to Reuben’s really bad idea. He just repeats, 

“My son will not go down there with you; his brother is dead and he is the only one left. If harm comes to him on the journey you are taking, you will bring my gray head down to the grave in sorrow.”

This is amazing literature, a millennia before Shakespeare. 

We have characters saying more than they know because, we as the readers, have the information. 

Notice, Jacob has both Joseph and Simeon, no longer existing. As for letting go of a third son?                           Ain’t gonna happen.

Hyperlink - back to the story of Abraham and Isaac. Abraham was asked to give up the son of Sarah, only to get him back again. And in the chapter before that test Abraham had to give up his first born son from Hagar by sending him and his mother out into the wilderness. As far as Abraham knew he was sending them to their death. So Abraham loses two sons, but gets one back. And yet, God saves the lives of both sons. 

This demonstrates how the Old Testament is meditation literature, at its best. When you begin to read it with the mindset of noticing pieces of a story that hyperlink back to previous stories and you begin to notice parallels and details that you hadn’t noticed the first time you read the story, you realize it’s not unintentional. 

It’s like poetry. It’s an art form of real dense communication that contains many layers that reveal themselves the more you read it and meditate on it and then you begin to see how it relates to your own life. 

Our story ends today with Jacob holding fast, and not budging. He is not about to let Benjamin go. You almost begin to feel sorry for him a little bit. He has been a bit of a scoundrel and selfish to the core, but when he begins to lose his sons, it seems sad. 

At this point, the brothers are stuck. 

Reuben, the oldest brother, attempts to find a solution.  Yet he’s a complex character. At one point he tries to take over the family through sexual abuse of his father’s wives and concubine, which by the way gets repeated by David’s son Absalom. Then Reuben seems to be the good guy by trying to keep Joseph from being killed. 

Now, he’s offering his own son’s lives as collateral in order to be given the chance to return Joseph to his father. It’s difficult to know just what Reuben is thinking.

Check in time. 

Have you noticed the complexity of all these characters? On a first reading, it feels like a very simple story. Yet, we have been reading about really realistic portrayals of human behavior and motives in psychology. These stories provide us an insight into human nature better than any novel you could pick up, even the classics. 

That is intentional. 

Scripture is all about the human story. 

The whole story began with characters whose names meant, “Human” and “Living One.” From Adam and Eve, the story is about people repeating what they had done. Even though Adam and Eve may seem a little fantastical, who can’t see a little bit of themselves in all of these characters? 

The best part of connecting our lives to those lives we read about in Scripture is that eventually, when we get to the New Testament, God shows up, in person, and demonstrates what  humans should have done in the first place. He becomes the perfect human.                                He also becomes the perfect sacrifice. 

Remember? 

The blood is required. 

Jesus fulfills that requirement, once and for all. 

Lord’s Supper. 



Sermon Details
Date: Nov 01, 2026
Speaker: Pastor Marilee Harris